Can transparency promote resource governance?
Transparency and accountability initiatives have emerged as a potential solution to combat corruption and increase public benefits from the extractive sector in resource-abundant countries. The Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI) is one such initiative, through which 49 resource-rich countries have disclosed a cumulative 282 fiscal years of government revenues amounting to US$1.9 trillion since 2003.
Eric Werker, Dr. Nadja Kunz, and Delgermaa Boldbaatar from the EITI Mongolia have developed and applied a new framework to consider how transparency initiatives (such as EITI) could enhance citizen empowerment and ultimately improve resource governance. The authors unfolded and evaluated the evidence in a recently published research article stemming from their work. The article can be downloaded directly from the following link.
The paper explores the potential for promised benefits of increased disclosure to be realized, in the form of improved resource governance. Building on the social accountability literature, a framework is proposed and then applied to the Mongolian context to examine which stages of the framework work well, and which fail to perform. Two types of contracts are analyzed, water usage agreements and community benefit-sharing agreements. Although Mongolia is recognized as a leading performer by international EITI standards, the analysis concludes that the framework’s latter stages from disclosure to improved resource governance are incomplete. The policy implication is that greater attention to mobilization and citizen empowerment is needed to ensure that contract transparency can meaningfully contribute towards improved governance
- Transparency initiatives have emerged in efforts to combat corruption and increase public benefits from the extractives sector.
- We explore the effectiveness of resource contract transparency for increasing public benefits from the extractives sector.
- A framework is developed and applied in Mongolia to consider how transparency could improve resource governance.
- The stages of the framework are found to be incomplete in our case studies of water usage and benefit-sharing agreements.
- Future research should consider how transparency can enhance citizen empowerment and ultimately improve resource governance.